PubHealth.info® (An Information Portal on Public Health Issues / Topics, Presented in Collaboration with PakMed Biomedical Solutions)

[PubHealth.info Homepage] [Category Homepage] [Disclaimer/Copyrights] [Feedback]

Thank you for your kind visit to PubHealth.info®, an information portal created in technical collaboration with PakMed Biomedical Solutions * * * PubHealth.info® presents hundreds of thousands of informative Web pages on a variety of public health issues / issues * * * An ultimate source of information for teachers, students and research workers who need to find information on various public health issues, like population planning, contraception, HIV AIDS, STDs, maternal and child health, communicable and non-communicable disease, etc. * * * PubHealth.info® regularly updates the repository of these hundreds of thousands of informative Web pages * * * PubHealth.info® is one of the world's largest repositories and information portals with online Web pages on public health issues particularly those pertaining to developing countries!

PubHealth.info® (a subsidiary of PakMed) presents scientific information mainly based on abstracts of articles published on a variety of public health issues/topics, particularly encompassing population planning, disease prevention, maternal and child health, and communicable and non-communicable diseases (like HIV AIDS, malaria, etc) that are affecting a significant portion of population in developing and developed countries. Here you can find abstracts of articles published on a variety of public health topics under category "Contraception (Birth Control) and Family Planning". Contraception (birth control) is a regimen of one or more actions, devices, or medications followed in order to deliberately prevent or reduce the likelihood of a woman becoming pregnant or giving birth. Therefore contraception is the utilization of various and sundry surgical procedures, devices, practices, agents, or drugs with the intention of preventing conception or impregnation (pregnancy). Methods and intentions typically termed birth control may be considered a pivotal ingredient to family planning. Birth control is a controversial political and ethical issue in many cultures and religions, and although it is generally less controversial than abortion specifically.





YEAR: 1983




CATEGORY: Contraception (Birth Control) and Family Planning



TITLE



Postcoital contraception [letter]



AUTHORS

McGuinness MN


SOURCE

Lancet. 1983 May 14;1(8333):1107.



ABSTRACT

The final paragraph of your April 16 editorial begs the question on the ethical issues and because of this I cannot

accept that postcoital methods can be "classified as contraceptive rather than abortive." Such an assertion can only

confuse the issue for those who have no ethical objection to preventing fertilization (i.e., to contraception proper) but

who find the deliberate prevention of implantation of a fertilized ovum ethically and morally unacceptable, and even

repugnant. In achieving in vitro fertilization scientists have established what reason and common sense asserts--

that with fertilization a new human life begins, which is distinct from the life of the progenitors. The onus of proof

rests on those who assert otherwise. If we accept that it is "illogical to assign to the unsuccessful or not-yet-

successful blastocyst the same value as is rightly given to human life after blacentation" because "more than 1/2 of

all fertilized eggs are lost in the menstrual flow" then we must conclude that the life of a 22-week fetus is less

valuable than that of the newborn baby or that the life of a baby is less valuable than that of the adult because so

many fail to survive. Indeed on the same reasoning we could assert that the life of infants in the 3rd World are less

valuable than those of children in developed countries. You rightly assert that "woman's uncertainty about the ethics

of this intervention" is a contraindication to postcoital contraception. This would imply that the onus is on the doctor

to clarify the mode of action of any methods of "contraception" suggested. It is only in the light of such knowledge

that a woman can give informed consent. Such an informed consent could only be given in the clear understanding

that the difference between a fertilized ovum and an unfertilized ovum is 1 of essence whereas the difference

between a fertilized ovum is merely 1 of time, development, and location. (PubHealth.info Document ID: CONT5T

2091-06)



PubHealth.info NOTE: The author(s) of this article titled, "Postcoital contraception [letter]", is(are) McGuinness MN.

The source of this article is "Lancet. 1983 May 14;1(8333):1107.". This article was published in 1983 in English

language(s). (PubHealth.info® Document ID: CONT5T 2091-06. All rights reserved with PubHealth.info) PIN: 22091






 

 

Web

PubHealth.info

© Copyrights PubHealth.info®, an information portal on public health. All rights reserved.

This page is optimized to be viewed by Java script enabled Microsoft® Internet Explorer 6 or later version, at screen resolution of 800 by 600 pixels.